Silly question - One eye closed or both eyes open?

If you would like to post, you'll need to register. Note that if you have a BCG store account, you'll need a new, separate account here (we keep the two sites separate for security purposes).

I was recently at a Mark Smith workshop, and I was talking to him and his son about tracking birds in flight and finding the subject in the frame at long focal lengths. Up until this point, I had always shot with one eye closed. They suggested I try both eyes open, and it seemed to help a lot, especially with hand-(lens)-eye coordination at 600mm. So, I wanted to ask if people have thoughts on this. Does everyone shoot with both eyes open? This is wildlife/bird focused. I imagine that for landscapes, it could be detrimental.
Both when tracking fast moving subject when I need to be aware of more than what is just in the VF. BUT for everything else one eye only.
 
It brings home the magnification of the viewfinder. The 'world' is a little bigger if the magnification is less than one.

I think I look over the top of the lens hood with one eye to 'spot' then try to force the other eye open when viewfinding, mostly unsuccessful.
 
Yeah - I was struggling with finding subjects at the long end of my lens. I've always had to zoom out to the widest end, find the subject, and then zoom in. Sometimes this is fine, but the subject often moves by the time I get back to 600mm. Having both eyes open helped me find the subject at 600mm.
This is other article I was looking for, and in fact it applies to accurate shooting with a rifle as well as shotgun, especially instinctive shooting.
There's a similar tactic that works well with framing a small bird in binoculars. This is to fix both eyes on the bird, and then simply raise the binos to your eyes. With a little practice, this works with a Telephoto to frame camouflaged subjects

 
Last edited:
I forgot how to test for my dominant eye, I tried a couple times using both eyes, I get distracted. I’m a super detailed brain, and my eyes seeing too much is a distraction, I can’t focus on the EVF. I would rather spin the focus ring
 
I forgot how to test for my dominant eye, I tried a couple times using both eyes, I get distracted. I’m a super detailed brain, and my eyes seeing too much is a distraction, I can’t focus on the EVF. I would rather spin the focus ring
Make an "O" with forefinger and thumb, hold it at arms length, and then while looking threw it at an object, slowly bring it to your face. It will come to the dominant eye,
 
Last edited:
I was recently at a Mark Smith workshop, and I was talking to him and his son about tracking birds in flight and finding the subject in the frame at long focal lengths. Up until this point, I had always shot with one eye closed. They suggested I try both eyes open, and it seemed to help a lot, especially with hand-(lens)-eye coordination at 600mm. So, I wanted to ask if people have thoughts on this. Does everyone shoot with both eyes open? This is wildlife/bird focused. I imagine that for landscapes, it could be detrimental.
Usually both eyes opened.
 
I tried sticking a match stick on the set up, on the lens hood, my 'back sight' was where the flash fits. Might try it again. I shoot a rifle using my right eye, but normally look through the viewfinder with my left. I'm in the process of teaching my right eye to look through the viewfinder. Next opportunity I will try photographing BiF with both eyes open.
I'm slowing down these days so the chances of me changing camera settings in the length of time it takes to photograph a bird in flight is non existent.
 
Back
Top