Trouble focus stacking using Lightroom/Photoshop

If you would like to post, you'll need to register. Note that if you have a BCG store account, you'll need a new, separate account here (we keep the two sites separate for security purposes).

Is anyone else finding that they can't load files to be focus stacked from Lightroom to Photoshop. I ask it to open as 'layers in photoshop' - it opens a few files and then stops, opens a final single file as a separate image and then halts completely. Sometimes when I first open the apps it will work - once and then refuse to work again. Has anyone found a solution? Thanks, Mick
 
[QUOTE = "Mick, message: 1098, membre: 1659"]
Est-ce que quelqu'un d'autre constate qu'il ne peut pas charger les fichiers à empiler de Lightroom vers Photoshop? Je lui demande de s'ouvrir en tant que `` calques dans Photoshop '' - il ouvre quelques fichiers puis s'arrête, ouvre un seul fichier final en tant qu'image séparée, puis s'arrête complètement. Parfois, lorsque j'ouvre les applications pour la première fois, cela fonctionne - une fois, puis je refuse de travailler à nouveau. Est-ce que quelqu'un a trouvé une solution? Merci, Mick
[/CITATION]
non, moi aussi problème
 
I have not experienced this issue. My first thought is you may have an issue with memory or the settings in the Photoshop. I just successfully opened 8 dng files as layers in PS from LR on my wife's 2020 MBP with 16 g of memory using PS default settings. you should check with Adobe for help.
 
[QUOTE = "Mundj, message: 1344, membre: 1709"]
Je n'ai pas rencontré ce problème. Ma première pensée est que vous avez peut-être un problème de mémoire ou de paramètres dans Photoshop. Je viens d'ouvrir avec succès 8 fichiers dng en tant que couches dans PS à partir de LR sur le MBP 2020 de ma femme avec 16 g de mémoire en utilisant les paramètres par défaut de PS. vous devriez vérifier auprès d'Adobe pour obtenir de l'aide.
[/CITATION]
Merci pour l'info, j'ai vérifié et je pense que c'est un problème de mémoire
 
I don't think it is a problem with memory - I have been using this method for months now and not had any problems. I am talking about opening 30-40 images in a stack but with 32gb of memory this has never been a problem before.
 
Is anyone else finding that they can't load files to be focus stacked from Lightroom to Photoshop. I ask it to open as 'layers in photoshop' - it opens a few files and then stops, opens a final single file as a separate image and then halts completely. Sometimes when I first open the apps it will work - once and then refuse to work again. Has anyone found a solution? Thanks, Mick
I am having the same problem Mick. I assumed it was because of not enough memory in my old iMac (8 gb) but I see from the conversation that you do not think that memory is the issue. Let us know if you find a solution.
 
It could indeed be memory. According to Adobe, the older 32-bit version of Photoshop is capable of using up to 3.2 gb of RAM, the newer 64-bit version "as much as you can give." Try this (on a Mac--Windows procedure is similar): In Photoshop, open Preferences > Performance. Under "Memory Usage," move the slider to "let Photoshop use" 70 to 75% of available RAM (recommended for optimal performance). You can set your History States lower (e.g., 20 or 30) which will lessen use of RAM. Set Cache Levels to 4. You can also open the Mac's Activity Monitor (Applications > Utilities > Activity Monitor) and click on the "Memory" tab at the top of the screen. This will show you just how much memory each application and process is using at any given time. On my computer, with Photoshop open but inactive, it is consuming 3.06 gb of available memory. I'd suggest closing all other unneeded programs and applications before starting your work in PS, since some apps working in the background (notably web browsers) will spike their usages of RAM (you can see this in Activity Monitor) for no apparent reason. I am no computer expert, but I've worked on Macs for over 30 years. Since you say the stacking process sometimes works when you first open the program, what is likely happening is that when first opened PS is "clean" and using minimal RAM. Once you start working with it, the caches, history states, and other processes start to kick in utilizing progressively more RAM. If you bump up against the max, PS will punish you by not completing the process, crashing, or running glacially slow. I could be totally wrong, as your 32gb of memory should be more than adequate, but at least it doesn't cost anything (or screw up anything) to try adjusting PS preferences. Hope this might help--good luck.
 
Thanks so much BirdDogDad! Your post is consistent with my experience and my iMac (running Mojave which I believe is 32-bit with 8 g of memory). Once I have watched the Canucks-Blues game, I will play with the PS preferences.
 
You are most welcome. I've been watching that game myself, although I'm an Avalanche fan. Yeah, 8gb is pretty marginal, unfortunately. Don't know if you could have RAM added to your iMac or not, but RAM is pretty cheap these days. RAM is like money--you can never have too much. Hopefully you can get your trusty machine to cooperate. Stay with your 32-bit OS as long as you can. The new iOS (Catalina) will not run any 32-bit applications, which means a whole lot of expense for software "upgrades." Hope your team wins. --Tom (my real name)
 
Hi BirdDogDad - thanks for your reply. I have always had Photoshop set to 75% of available RAM and for the last 12-18 months I have been able to work with focus stacked images with no problems. This just suddenly started a couple of days ago - and I had not changed anything. Thanks anyway!!
 
This problem appeared on my IBM style PC (64Gb ram, I9 processor) with a recent PS CC update, the solution, according to Adobe support is to erase your preferences.
I use stacking quite often so I tried removing preferences and subsequently had no problems.

However, I did not appreciate having to re-apply my customizations so restored them from a backup and haven't had the time to find out which setting(s) was causing the trouble.
My work around is to reboot the computer, then stacking works fine if it is the 1st thing you do.
-Jay-
 
This link has some info on your preferences.

In my case I found the path to the presets as stated in the article and after backing them up I erased them. A new set of preferences was generated when I re-started PS CC.
 
Mick, see also this article: https://www.photoshopessentials.com/basics/reset-photoshop-preferences/

This article describes how to completely delete the Photoshop preferences file. Many times over the years--at least on my Macs--deleting the preferences file was the only (and often last-ditch) solution to many software problems, not just Adobe products. As the article describes, preference files often have a habit of becoming corrupted and/or unnecessarily bloated. If possible, keep a backup of your original preferences file just in case. But, I've never encountered a problem deleting a pref file, since the program simply makes a new one when you next open it. Only downside is you will have to redo any particular customization and presets you've done, as the newly created pref file will revert to program defaults, but that is a minor irritation compared to a program that simply won't work.
 
I restored my preferences from another computer and it still requires a reboot before stacking layers, so something in Adobe's update seems to have corrupted the preferences on 2 of my machines.
What ever the actual setting(s) that cause the problem they aren't saying.
-Jay-
 
I won't pretend to have the technical expertise to offer an accurate diagnosis, but it might be possible that "restoring" preferences could carry over some degree of original corruption that would be eliminated by a complete deletion of the preference files, and the corresponding rebuild of a "fresh" file when the program restarts. Don't hang your hat on this amateur opinion, but I've seen it happen. Good luck.
 
This problem appeared on my IBM style PC (64Gb ram, I9 processor) with a recent PS CC update, the solution, according to Adobe support is to erase your preferences.
I use stacking quite often so I tried removing preferences and subsequently had no problems.

However, I did not appreciate having to re-apply my customizations so restored them from a backup and haven't had the time to find out which setting(s) was causing the trouble.
My work around is to reboot the computer, then stacking works fine if it is the 1st thing you do.
-Jay-

My stacking problem has persisted even after erasing preferences. I have been in contact with Adobe Customer Care on a nearly daily basis for half a month, had my case elevated to a higher level, completely erased all PS, Lightroom and related 'Apps' and reinstalled to no avail.
Finally in my daily talk to them they found a problem with their code, said others have been experiencing the same problem as I and reverted my PS CC to 21.0.0.

They said this would be addressed in their next release.

-Jay-
 
Is anyone else finding that they can't load files to be focus stacked from Lightroom to Photoshop. I ask it to open as 'layers in photoshop' - it opens a few files and then stops, opens a final single file as a separate image and then halts completely. Sometimes when I first open the apps it will work - once and then refuse to work again. Has anyone found a solution? Thanks, Mick
I spent 2 hrs on phone with tech and she was able to create the issue too. Said she was sending it to developers to fix. Not sure yet they have on new upgrade.
 
It seems to be fixed in version 22.0.0.

When prompted during the install I elected to import preferences from 21.0.0 and have succeeded in repeated D850 full frame stacks up to 20 subs so far.
My problem would occur sooner when I closed PS after each stacking session, and especially if I ran an adjustment or filter after compositing. PS froze and required Task Manager to unwedge it, and then a reboot to successfully stack again.

All seems good now.
-Jay-
 
Back
Top