Robin Work
Well-known member
- Post score: 14
- #1
Barn surrounded by Fall Color
- Thread starter Robin Work
- Start date
If you would like to post, you'll need to register. Note that if you have a BCG store account, you'll need a new, separate account here (we keep the two sites separate for security purposes).
- Post score: 1
- #2
A nice scene here. IMO it would be improved if the barn was off center. Maybe consider cropping to a 4x5 format with all of the removed area taken from the right side of the frame. Also maybe try to pull more detail out of the sky.
Robin Work
Well-known member
- Post score: 4
- #3
I couldn't get anymore out of the sky so I just replaced it with a sky similar to what it actually was that day. And I used a different picture of the same thing so I could remove from the right side. What do you think?
Robin Work
Well-known member
- Post score: 4
- #4
I couldn't get anymore out of the sky so I just replaced it with a sky similar to what it actually was that day. What do you think?
View attachment 27912
Gary Dietz
Active member
I like the second one better
Huge improvement IMO.
Bill Schone
Well-known member
Second one also, very nice!
Which one do you like best? It really doesn't matter what any of us think, what you like is what's the most important. I like the sky better on the 2nd one (you replaced it). I don't like that stump sticking out of the water on number 2. There are elements on both that appeal to me. However, it's what you like that is the most important.
Robin Work
Well-known member
- Post score: 4
- #9
I think I still like the first one best except for the sky. But I enjoy hearing and seeing another prospective and trying different things, so I like both.