BenQ SW217

If you would like to post, you'll need to register. Note that if you have a BCG store account, you'll need a new, separate account here (we keep the two sites separate for security purposes).

I am considering upgrading my monitor for photo editing. I primarily use Lightroom Classic version 10 for editing RAW images but I do use Photoshop for specific tasks. The monitor I am considering is the BenQ SW217. Does anyone have experience with this monitor in their photo editing?
 
Hi... I am guessing you might mean the BenQ SW271 monitor.
If so this is what I am currently using. I wanted a decent monitor and the online reviews were positive for this BenQ model. I could not justify/afford an Eizo monitor and am extremely happy with my BenQ.

It is easy to calibrate, enjoyable to use and I suggest delivers excellent and accurate image quality to screen.

I do recommend. Good luck with your decision and monitor outcome...
 
Craig, I appreciate your response.
I have also read a number of reviews. Some of these reviews mention a green color cast on the monitor, did you experience this? How long have you been using the BenQ SW271 monitor ? Are you using Lightroom Classic as your image editing software?
Thanks... John (aka JVG)
 
Craig, I appreciate your response.
I have also read a number of reviews. Some of these reviews mention a green color cast on the monitor, did you experience this? How long have you been using the BenQ SW271 monitor ? Are you using Lightroom Classic as your image editing software?
Thanks... John (aka JVG)
Hi John,

I've had my BenQ for just under 12 months. I do use Lightroom Classic and am happy with this setup/combination.
I have also seen some reviews comment about the colour cast, but I cannot say I have experienced this with my setup and monitor. In electronic calibration of the monitor and with physical colour card comparisons (for printing purposes) to my eyes the BenQ optically appears accurate.
Cheers, Craig
 
What computer will you be connecting this SW271 to? If a PC, ignore this post-- I don't know how Windows scaling works. If a Mac, read on.

Most computers, either Mac or PC, can easily drive 4K these days, but be aware that if you are using a Mac, the pixel density of this display (163 PPI) may require a scaled display setting that will put a strain on your computer, perhaps reducing its performance, and slightly reducing image quality.

True 2:1 "retina" scaling would be easiest for a Mac and give you excellent image quality and extremely sharp text, but that also would give you the UI equivalent of a 27" low-resolution 1080p display running at 81.5 PPI with monstrously large text and UI controls, and a feeling of not having enough space to do normal work.

1:1 scaling, driving the UI at full 4k resolution, will also result in excellent image quality but the text and UI controls will be too small to read and cause eye strain.

You'll likely settle on an intermediate scaling setting that will result in a comfortable text/UI size for the average person. But you should know, technically everything will be ever-so-slightly blurred, and your system will be working a lot harder to render to a virtual resolution greater than 4k (likely 5k) while then resizing that down to 4k resolution, 60 times a second. The downsampling to 4k is the cause of the slight blurriness and also means you'll never really be able to truly view your images at 1:1, or 1 image pixel to 1 monitor pixel.

Practically speaking this may not matter to you. Many people use these intermediate scaling settings all the time and never notice issues with them. You likely won't see the blurriness in normal usage. In fact, all MacBook Pros, either 13", 15", or 16", have been driving their built-in screens at these weird scaling factors for at least the past 5 years and it hasn't created an uproar.

But if you're going to drop over $1000 on an external monitor, I believe you should know the trade-offs, make sure your computer can handle the scaling without getting bogged down, and know you may be looking at your images scaled down from a higher-resolution rendering, not true 1:1. Caveat emptor, as they say.

Here's a good article describing the issue that demonstrates the blurring effect of these intermediate scaling settings:

 
Brain

I am using a window based desktop system. Since I am currently suing an HP Z27 4k monitor, I am familiar with the font scaling issue. I do, however, appreciate your explanation of this scaling issue.

Thanks...
JVG
 
I believe with windows you need a Quadro card to get the full color space of the monitor. In my case I had a prefabbed PC and was ablt to get a NVIDIA QUADRO card that fit. It was not easy finding that card. I did learn that I will not buy a prefabbed PC in the future.
 
I believe with windows you need a Quadro card to get the full color space of the monitor. In my case I had a prefabbed PC and was ablt to get a NVIDIA QUADRO card that fit. It was not easy finding that card. I did learn that I will not buy a prefabbed PC in the future.

Nope that used to be the case.
Nowadays the GTX and RTX cards come with a Studio driver (able to output 10 bit per channel) and a normal (programmed for 8bit per channel and speed) Game Ready driver.

 
Nope that used to be the case.
Nowadays the GTX and RTX cards come with a Studio driver (able to output 10 bit per channel) and a normal (programmed for 8bit per channel and speed) Game Ready driver.

Thanks for the update Thern. I still do not think I will ever buy another prefab PC - just too many limitations with upgrading components - you are literally boxed in.
 
The new PC I purchased is from Puget Systems and is designed and build to run Lightroom/Photoshop efficiently and fast. It will have the NVIDIA's GeForce RTX 3070 card installed.

The benchmark results running Lightroom V10 are impressive.
 
Craig, I appreciate your response.
I have also read a number of reviews. Some of these reviews mention a green color cast on the monitor, did you experience this? How long have you been using the BenQ SW271 monitor ? Are you using Lightroom Classic as your image editing software?
Thanks... John (aka JVG)

I've had the BenQ SW 217 for over a year and am using it as my main editing monitor in LR and PS. I have not noted any color cast. I use my NEC Multisync PA241W as a secondary monitor. Both are calibrated with iDisplay Pro and the colors on both are very similar. My video card is the GeForce GTX 1060 GB.

I would recommend the SW 217. It is a bargain compared to the professional NEC and Eizo monitors.

Bill
 
I've had the BenQ SW 217 for over a year and am using it as my main editing monitor in LR and PS. I have not noted any color cast. I use my NEC Multisync PA241W as a secondary monitor. Both are calibrated with iDisplay Pro and the colors on both are very similar. My video card is the GeForce GTX 1060 GB.

I would recommend the SW 217. It is a bargain compared to the professional NEC and Eizo monitors.

Bill

For the price you get a lot of monitor.
Wide Gamut, HW lut, UHD, 10 bit (8+2FRC), 27”, a hood and a handy puck.
Compared to NEC or Eizo the price is unbeatable.
No catch? Yes there’s one BIG one..
Sample variation.
Some screens are superb but there are allso screens with magenta/green colorcast, bad uniformity, uneven lighting aso.
Be sure to calibrate asap you get the monitor, test for these issues and send the screen back if it’s not good.
 
Last edited:
Back
Top