There are a few big advantages of Negative Lab Pro.
For a few dozen files, I would not care. For a large project of hundreds of images, it's a very easy decision.
You still may end up using Topaz or other tools for specific images. As pointed out - many times these old negatives were not that sharp originally.
In using the ES2 and handling negatives, it best to be selective and clean the negatives or transparencies well before scanning. A minute or two on the front end can save hours of cleanup. Close viewing before scanning can reduce time wasted on images that really aren't good enough to justify much effort.
- You can keep all your files in original raw format. That eliminates redundant files and allows the best possible starting point for processing.
- It uses the standard LR sliders - not inverted sliders. This makes workflows and adjustments a lot easier.
- All adjustments can be cancelled, changed or adjusted further at any point.
- There are presets to expedite editing.
For a few dozen files, I would not care. For a large project of hundreds of images, it's a very easy decision.
You still may end up using Topaz or other tools for specific images. As pointed out - many times these old negatives were not that sharp originally.
In using the ES2 and handling negatives, it best to be selective and clean the negatives or transparencies well before scanning. A minute or two on the front end can save hours of cleanup. Close viewing before scanning can reduce time wasted on images that really aren't good enough to justify much effort.