QD connector failure

If you would like to post, you'll need to register. Note that if you have a BCG store account, you'll need a new, separate account here (we keep the two sites separate for security purposes).

Was carrying my Z8 on my peak design slide strap attached to my lens foot (Kirk) with a QD connector. The internal mechanism of the QD broke the lens was fine as I think the camera body hit the ground first. The Z8 has a broken IBIS and sensor It’s out to Nikon for repair. Has this ever happened to anyone else? The QD is most convenient as you just unlock and put the foot on a tripod without having to remove anything else. Would you trust it again and what do you use to attach a lens foot to your straps?
Never had this experience, and hope that I never do! So sorry for your misfortune. Just a FYI, my PD strap has two QDs attached - the main one snaps into the lens foot, and the other one into the camera base plate via a little "safety" strap. If you try the QD again, you might think about adding a safety strap & secondary QD to the setup. Good luck!

IMG_2214.jpeg
You can only see EXIF info for this image if you are logged in.
 
Last edited:
Two is one and one is none. I'm a firm believer in a backup tether. I use QDs on both the main strap and the tether - one connected to the lens foot on the main strap and the tether connects to the L-Bracket that permanently is affixed to my Z9. The tether is just snug and there just to stop the camera from hitting the ground (hopefully) as I scramble to grab it. I can have the camera off and on a tripod or just use it freehand in 2 seconds.
IMG_2902.jpeg
You can only see EXIF info for this image if you are logged in.
 
Last edited:

My setup does not have a knob. It appears to be very secure.

View attachment 110635
This setup as pictured is false security IMO. When these things break, it will be where that swivel head attaches to the loop that the strap is affixed to. That head will 'pop' off and the entire rig will hit the ground - backup tether and all (I've seen several dog collar swivels break just like I'm describing). I would strongly recommend affixing that tether to the actual loop ring that the strap is affixed to. Not much chance of that loop breaking, which will make the tether effective. YMMV
 
This setup as pictured is false security IMO. When these things break, it will be where that swivel head attaches to the loop that the strap is affixed to. That head will 'pop' off and the entire rig will hit the ground - backup tether and all (I've seen several dog collar swivels break just like I'm describing). I would strongly recommend affixing that tether to the actual loop ring that the strap is affixed to. Not much chance of that loop breaking, which will make the tether effective. YMMV
I see what you are saying. I personally have never heard of that occurring but I could see how it could happen. I’ve now moved the tether connection up to the ring. Thanks!😎
 
I see what you are saying. I personally have never heard of that occurring but I could see how it could happen. I’ve now moved the tether connection up to the ring. Thanks!😎
You're welcome. I've never seen it in the context of camera gear either, but best to be a little safer. Easy peasy. Below is an example of a dog leash like I'm talking about. That post can wear down and break, or even the head can pop off. Would be horrible for sure.
 

Attachments

  • 874371_81_83682_j4spxN6tL.jpg
    874371_81_83682_j4spxN6tL.jpg
    155.7 KB · Views: 31
Make sense if you are sitting, until the one time something happens. Generally I don't use a strap when on Safari. Then a camera nearly slips out of my hand and the straps go back on. Luckily I have never lost a camera.
I have seen a camera dropped from a Land Cruiser right in front of a lion. Fortunately, the lion got bored before we had to return to the camp 🦁📷
 
Two is one and one is none. I'm a firm believer in a backup tether. I use QDs on both the main strap and the tether - one connected to the lens foot on the main strap and the tether connects to the L-Bracket that permanently is affixed to my Z9. The tether is just snug and there just to stop the camera from hitting the ground (hopefully) as I scramble to grab it. I can have the camera off and on a tripod or just use it freehand in 2 seconds.View attachment 110649
Good solution
 
You're welcome. I've never seen it in the context of camera gear either, but best to be a little safer. Easy peasy. Below is an example of a dog leash like I'm talking about. That post can wear down and break, or even the head can pop off. Would be horrible for sure.
If the dog get loose, that could spell real trouble .. The few times out Golden pulled her head out of the collar, she was so surprised, she just sat down and waited for me to put the collar back on. Otherwise ...
 
Never had this experience, and hope that I never do! So sorry for your misfortune. Just a FYI, my PD strap has two QDs attached - the main one snaps into the lens foot, and the other one into the camera base plate via a little "safety" strap. If you try the QD again, you might think about adding a safety strap & secondary QD to the setup. Good luck!

View attachment 110636
Great security but takes an extra step to detach the camera from the strap. If you don't need to put the camera on a trilpod, extra 5-10 second probably will not matter.
 
Why most of the pictures above have a secondary tether attached to a single point of failure?

If you use a closed loop strap, the least prone to failure part is the strap itself (given you sometimes check the sewing and the strap itself ... but a 20mm polyamid strap can take a lot of beating). Just use a sort of carabiner/dring/chain/whatever to slide along the QD/arca clamp etc.

I would also - in terms of failure rate QD higher than using an arca clamp (even tho they have tensioners inside) and carabiner with a loop screwed into the foot (I have seen gear in a stream because blackrapid eyelet screwed out of the lenfoot - it did not fail, but you DO have to tension the rubber a lot. No loctite was used).

This is the set up I ALMOST use:
1744099529188.png


Mine was moded, so I do not use the screw and carabiner. I have sewn a strap with a QD (nylon strap was used) and kept the metal slider. the second backup/redundant slider has a PD anchor, connected to the lens barrel. QD goes into lensfoot. Duraflex clip can take a lot of weight/shock. If only it is high quality. It has saved my lens once.

A blackrapid strap can be made/modded just as robust at this one is. Basicaly any solid strap is a nice starting point.
I like the stock leofoto strap as they can be adjusted really easily. However they close the loop by a QD and some sewing has to be done with them to improve their foolproofness.
I guess the easiest to adjust are military ferro concept straps. However, I have not tried one for photography yet (I have a knockoff somewere to check how adjusting works).
 

Attachments

  • 1744099496356.png
    1744099496356.png
    94.2 KB · Views: 29
Last edited:
I’ve been using a Blackrapid sling - I have a couple of them - with a QD connector, to a Hejnar replacement lens foot for almost the last 5 years and I’ve never had a problem. I do also use the Blackrapid quick release safety tether. For a while Blackrapid offered their slings with a QD connector instead of their carabiner system. I believe the QD connector was a Magpul. I once bought a couple of the cheap, Chinese made QD connectors from Amazon, but I was worried about the quality and never used them on my camera equipment.
 
I use these plates they are made in the USA not as pricey as the Kirk or RSS and they have 2 QD connections on the longer plates. The QD connectors are designed for I thind 220 pounds.
Chris Hejnar makes terrific products. I've bought several items from him over the years and I've always been highly impressed with both the quality and the pricing.
 
Back
Top