Emergency beacons, do you carry one?

If you would like to post, you'll need to register. Note that if you have a BCG store account, you'll need a new, separate account here (we keep the two sites separate for security purposes).

A Garmin InReach or similar device (with backup charger) would have avoided a potential disaster at sea. This photographer was fortunate to avoid seriously rough seas




Similar situation in Australia, which could have turned out fatal
Most places I go here in Australia have no cell phone coverage.
I've been planning to get a satellite phone (if they get cheap enough) .. 🦘
 
And iphone 14, 15, or 16 provides for satellite communication and is going to be adequate for sending text messages including ones GPS coordinates.

I traveled on land and far offshore before there was GPS or cell phones and needed to be prepared for emergencies and self reliant. Today people take stupid risks and then expect others to come and rescue them regardless of the risk to these other people.

A surf skier was rescued in Hawaii and this fellow did not tell people where he was going or provide an ETA and he did not take a phone or radio or flare and he had not bothered to tether his paddle to the boat. I have owned 6 kayaks and all had a line to tether the paddle to the boat.


The 10 Essentials are a good starting point for those off the beaten path:
 
I have engaged in sports which place your life at risk. When I was young we used to go backpacking iin upstate Pennsylvania in the middle of winter. 20 below zero.

I also scuba dove.

the secret to security is safety redundancy. I never went out in the wildehirness alone, I always had a friend with me.

they teach the buddy system in diving. the idea was you have a buddy to rely on if your gear fails.

the reality is particularly when diving relying on your buddy is illusory. I have dove in waters where you can barely see your hand in front of your face. If you have a prolblem under water you may have a minute to find an alternate air source. You turn right your buddy turns left all of a sudden you can't see your buddy. No anway you can count on him being there for you in one minute.

I then studied decompression diving. this is the kind of diving when you absolutely can't go to the surface whenever you want. You have to burn off nitrogen. It means you have to stay underwater perhaps a half hour or more before it is safe to come up.

they teach self sufficiency and redundancy. You have to have two of everything so in case one piece of equipment fails you have your own backup. You still dive with a buddy but you are also really self sufficient. You know that if one piece of equipment fails and you are down to your backup you stop the dive and get to the surface as soon as it is safe to do so.

Applying this theory to the InReach devices, the question is what happens if the device fails. Do you have backup? For instance are you with a buddy who has his own InReach device/? What if you make a mistake and you drain your batte3ry?

HAM radio is another way to get redundancy. You can call anywhere in the world with the right ham radiio equipment.

the moral of this story is don't put all your safety eggs ion one basket. Plan for equipment failure and have a backup or two.
 
Just don't be this guy....

 
I was 16 and snorkeling off Palos Verdes and my "buddy" went missing. I surfaced to find him practically running across the water to shore. I yelled at him WTF, he yelled SHARK. I looked down and sure enough, an 8 foot shark. He wasn't interested in me though and after he passed I headed casually for shore. Had the shark been aggressive I'm fairly certain my "buddy" would have drawn his attention. You don't have to be faster than the bear........

Years later I met Jack O'Neill who helped develop the wetsuit and pioneer SCUBA. He and his buddies bought surplus Air Force compressors which they ran on vegetable oil but still damaged their lungs.
 
Last edited:
I agree with some of what you say. However, consider for example someone who goes for a hike in relatively unchallenging conditions, slips and breaks a leg. That renders you immobile immediately and there's no reasonable way of getting back home alone. I can go further and say every time one leaves your home and ventures outside there is a certain amount of risk involved because you are not in control of the environment anymore.

So I think it's a matter of assessing the potential risks involved in the venture, assessing one's own abilities, deciding how much risk one is willing to accept (hopefully being realistic and honest with yourself), and then including plan B and C such as the ability to reach rescue services as a last resort.

As for the rescue folks, at least they have training and are capable of determining whether a specific rescue is too risky for them to attempt or not. And they volunteer for the job with a good understanding of the potential risks to their own safety that comes with the job.

I assume at least some of the rescue services are taxpayer-funded. As for making someone pay for a rescue, yeah, it can be considered, but only for cases where the rescued clearly displayed poor judgment and took unreasonable risks.
I frequently hike alone in the mountains.
I fully agree with everything you say
 
This has been an informative thread. I'm thinking of getting a Garmin or similar device especially since we do a lot of single vehicle desert travel (death valley, utah, anza borrego, etc) in an older but well maintained 4x4 toyota truck. We have a good shell plus sleeping platform and camp well away from the beaten path. But it has over 410k miles and we will probably replace it at some point soon.

I agree with others who emphasize being well prepared. I've spent a lifetime traveling the backcountry in a wide variety of conditions, seasons, and weather. I also use paper topo maps, compass together with a good phone map app. I have a small backup battery in my backpack and plan to get another larger one for the truck. We usually have about 30 gallons of water in the truck on one of our trips to start.

A question: has anyone used their Garmin or similar device to add GPS to their photos via Bluetooth or wifi link with snapbridge? My phone just doesn't work well for that. I may get a solmeta unit or equivalent.
Thanks for the good discussion.
 
Another thought, I know that my map and compass and orienteering skills suffer from disuse. I become reliant on my phone mapping app and don't use orienteering skills often enough.
As wotan said, redundancy is good. I try to have downloaded usgs topos on my phone, but back them up with paper topos when we visit areas that just aren't traveled.
 
A question: has anyone used their Garmin or similar device to add GPS to their photos via Bluetooth or wifi link with snapbridge? My phone just doesn't work well for that. I may get a solmeta unit or equivalent.
Thanks for the good discussion.
i'm not sure it's possible. if the phone doesn't work well enough (and i agree, i don't think it was reliable for me), then i think you need one of the nikon gps dongles.

luckily for me, i mostly use the z9, and just leave the onboard gps active
 
Back
Top